A Case of Independent Origination?

jobs

From the Shanghai Daily News:

A HONG Kong design student’s tribute to Steve Jobs that generated a buzz online following the death of the co-founder of Apple last week is not original, the teenager said yesterday.

Jonathan Mak, 19, said he was not the first to come up with the design that fits Jobs’ silhouette into the bite of the Apple logo (see right). He was speaking after comments surfaced on Twitter that a UK-based designer, known as Raid71 on the web, created the original design in May.

The design posted by Mak on the Internet spread like wildfire last Thursday, just after the passing of Jobs.

It drew hundreds of thousands of posts, commemorative caps and T-shirts peddled on eBay featured the design and it was used by Hollywood actor Ashton Kutcher as his Twitter profile picture.

Mak, a student at Hong Kong’s Polytechnic University School of Design, acknowledged he was not the original creator of the design but said he did not “rip off” the UK designer.

“I still arrived at the solution on my own, and my conscience is clear, but I’m more than happy to acknowledge the fact that somebody did it before me,” Mak said.

Like Mak’s design, the UK-based designer fits Jobs’ silhouette into the bite of the Apple logo. But the dimensions and proportions differ.